Essay
Who Profits From A Revolution?
The success of a technology breakthrough can threaten the advantage it creates.

Richard M. Murphy
·

The Tennis Court Oath, after Jacques-Louis David. Musée Carnavalet, Paris. CC0 / Paris Musées.
Jensen Huang’s abrupt departure from Nvidia has raised an obvious question: Can the company maintain its dominance without the founder who built it?
There’s another question, potentially more consequential. Can Nvidia continue to shape the future of AI computing as the architecture it helped establish becomes an industry standard?
Huang didn't invent artificial intelligence or pioneer the use of graphics processors for AI. But he made a long-term bet on GPU computing, building the hardware and software stack that would make Nvidia central to the AI revolution.
Nvidia did more than develop powerful chips. It helped establish an architecture for AI computing, spanning processors, networking, software and data centers. Huang gave that architecture a compelling narrative, positioning Nvidia's "AI factories" as a new industrial paradigm.
His departure leaves Nvidia facing a leadership crisis at a time when competitors and customers are increasingly seeking alternatives to the computing architecture it has made dominant.
These are two distinct challenges, but together they illuminate a paradox familiar to companies that successfully define new markets. The more completely a company sets the terms of competition, the more incentive it gives others to compete on those terms.
The scarcity problem
More than two decades ago, Nicholas Carr identified a similar dynamic in information technology. In “IT Doesn’t Matter,” his provocative 2003 Harvard Business Review essay, he argued that as computing became indispensable to business, it was losing its power to confer competitive advantage.
The headline was deliberately inflammatory. Carr wasn’t arguing that IT had become unimportant. Quite the opposite. Computing was becoming indispensable to business, much as railroads and electricity had transformed earlier generations of industry.
The more completely a company sets the terms of competition, the more incentive it gives others to compete on those terms.
But indispensability and competitive advantage are different things. A technology can become more valuable to the economy while becoming less distinctive to any company that uses it. As infrastructure spreads, costs fall and competitors gain access to similar capabilities, the advantage of early adoption diminishes.
Carr’s central insight was that competitive advantage depends on scarcity. Even indispensable technology loses its power to differentiate when everyone has access to it. Critics countered that companies could still gain an edge through how they used technology. But Carr had identified a broader competitive dynamic, one that applies not just to IT, but to the ideas companies use to define their markets.
Consider what happens when an innovative company identifies an emerging problem and develops a new way to address it. At first, the proposition may seem unfamiliar, even implausible. The company must educate customers, persuade analysts and establish a vocabulary for discussing something the market doesn’t yet fully understand.
If it succeeds, the language catches on. Customers begin describing their needs in those terms. Analysts adopt the framework, and competitors reposition their products accordingly. Eventually, what began as a distinctive insight becomes conventional wisdom. The company has won the argument. But the argument no longer distinguishes it from everyone else.
Claiming the category
I saw a version of this dynamic from inside ServiceNow. In 2018, I led the launch of Workflow, the company’s thought leadership publication. I chose the name because workflow was already a familiar industry term for the repeatable business processes that platforms like ServiceNow automate.
In November 2020, ServiceNow launched its “Let's workflow it” campaign as part of a broader shift toward workflow-centered branding. It was a happy coincidence for the publication, which benefited from the company's much larger investment in the concept.
A technology can become more valuable to the economy while becoming less distinctive to any company that uses it.
The alignment illustrated something important about category positioning. ServiceNow didn’t invent workflows. It sought to become the company most closely associated with making them work better across the enterprise. Rather than creating a category from scratch, it took an established concept and made it central to how customers understood the company’s ambitions.
That can be a powerful strategy, but association is not ownership. Competitors can adopt the same language, while customers’ expectations and the competitive terrain continue to evolve. ServiceNow has since moved beyond workflow-centered branding, even as the concept remains integral to its products and messaging. The framing helped explain the company’s ambitions at a particular stage in its development. It was never going to be the whole story.
What survives imitation
Business history is full of companies whose breakthroughs became industry standards, with mixed outcomes for the pioneers. One cautionary tale is TiVo, which transformed TV viewing by allowing people to pause live broadcasts, record programs and watch them whenever they wanted. Its name became a verb.
As cable and satellite operators incorporated similar functionality into their own equipment, TiVo lost much of what made it distinctive. The company helped redefine how people watched television without capturing a corresponding share of the market it created.
Business history is full of companies whose breakthroughs became industry standards, with mixed outcomes for the pioneers.
Salesforce took a different path. It challenged the shrink-wrapped software model by delivering CRM over the internet, making “No Software” the rallying cry for a new way of buying and using enterprise applications. By the time cloud delivery became standard, Salesforce had expanded beyond CRM into customer service, marketing and app development, building a platform and ecosystem that competitors couldn't easily match.
Both companies helped change what customers expected. But while TiVo struggled to capture the value of the market it helped create, Salesforce built a competitive position that endured after its original breakthrough became commonplace.
Nvidia’s third act
Nvidia has built advantages far more substantial than a persuasive narrative. Its processors, networking technologies, CUDA software ecosystem and deep relationships with developers and customers form an integrated platform that competitors cannot easily reproduce. The company has translated its vision of accelerated computing into technical capabilities, commercial relationships and an ecosystem that reinforces its position.
The scale of Nvidia’s success has created powerful incentives for the industry to reduce its dependence on that platform. Google and Amazon have developed their own AI chips, while AMD, Intel and a growing field of specialized chipmakers are challenging Nvidia's dominance. Its largest customers have powerful financial and strategic reasons to reduce their dependence on a single supplier.
None of this proves that Nvidia is about to lose its leadership. Its integrated platform may remain the preferred choice for many AI workloads, and the company has repeatedly demonstrated an ability to innovate ahead of competitors. Still, as AI infrastructure matures, customers will increasingly judge competing approaches on performance, cost, flexibility and the degree of control they provide.
The reward for changing the rules of a market is that your competitors get to play by them.
That evolution poses a challenge different from the one Nvidia faced when accelerated computing was still an emerging proposition. Huang helped persuade the industry that AI required a new computing architecture. Now that the industry has embraced that vision, Nvidia must defend its position in a market where competitors are investing heavily in alternative ways to deliver on it.
Huang’s sudden departure adds uncertainty because he played such an outsized role in defining Nvidia’s direction and persuading the industry to follow along. But his vision was only part of the achievement. Nvidia’s future will depend on whether the company can continue turning that vision into technical innovation, commercial advantage and an ecosystem competitors struggle to replicate.
Careful now
This illustrates why “IT Doesn’t Matter” remains relevant more than two decades after Carr published the essay. A technology, business model or organizing idea may become increasingly important even as its original novelty loses competitive value. What matters is whether the company that established the proposition has used its early advantage to build a competitive position that endures after the original innovation becomes commonplace.
For companies seeking to define new markets, that’s both the opportunity and the danger. A compelling idea can reshape customer expectations, attract investment, influence competitors and establish a company as the reference point for an emerging industry. But when a company's vision becomes the accepted definition of a market category, competitors adopt its language, eroding the distinction that gave it an early advantage.
In the end, the reward for changing the rules of a market is that your competitors get to play by them.
How we use AI
Walled City uses AI as part of its editorial process—the same human-led approach we use to help clients build market authority at scale. We deploy AI as a tool for ideation, research and drafting. Our essays draw on original reporting, proprietary data, experience, sustained revision, and human verification. Walled City remains fully responsible for the ideas, judgment, accuracy, and final work.



